Propaganda Techniques and the Engineering of Consent in the West's Civilizational War Against Russia During the Crimean War
https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2025-3-76-3-16
Abstract
Introduction. The article analyzes the genesis of British Russophobia and anti-Russian propaganda in the period from the Vienna Congress of 1815 to the Crimean War (1853–1855) and the Paris Congress of 1856. The subject of the study is pre-war, pre-war and military propaganda in Great Britain and the tools used. The aim of the study is the genesis of global anti-Russian propaganda and Russophobia. The role of K. Marx and F. Engels in the propaganda campaign initiated by lobbyists for the war with the Russian Empire is separately studied in order to show the identity of the anti-Russian and Russophobic theses of the communists (i.e. the counter-elites of Western civilization) and the most aggressive towards Russia representatives of the military and political elites of the British Empire, which became the center of Western civilization in the 19th century.
Materials and methods. The study is based on the materials of Russian, British and American authors. The methodology of the study is based on the civilizational approach in the context of the system analysis of international relations. Within the framework of this methodology, the historical-genetic method (retrospective analysis), descriptive, analytical, and comparative methods were also used to analyze the factual material.
Research results. The results obtained revealed a stable stereotype regarding Russia that was formed during that period, which eventually became part of the British heroic mythology and even later a presetting for Western society. The phenomenon of the super-active anti-Russian propaganda activities of Marx and Engels, their publication of similar articles in European and American media, was highlighted, which for the first time allows us to talk about the work of the internationalist communists Marx and Engels on the anti-Russian propaganda campaign, which is part of the large information war of Western civilization against Russian civilization.
Discussion and conclusion. A thesis is put forward about a symbiotic pair of Western civilization and the international financial and information consortium, the prototype of modern globalist structures. For the first time, a thesis has been put forward about the transformation of propaganda into a social practice in Great Britain during that period. Conclusions have been made about the need to take into particular account the British stereotypical vision of Crimea, Russia and Russian civilization when analyzing and forecasting
About the Author
M. Yu. KoshmarovRussian Federation
Mikhail Yu. Koshmarov, Candidate of Technical Sciences,
Director for development of innovative technologies
Moscow, Russia
References
1. Anisimov O.V., 2010. Franko-russkij konflikt vokrug Svyatykh mest Palestiny: periodizaciya i ee znachenie [The FrenchRussian conflict over the Holy Sites of Palestine: periodization and its significance]. Trudy kafedry istorii Novogo i Novejshego vremeni [Proceedings of the Department of the Modern and Contemporary History]. № 4.
2. Arendt H., 2020. Istoki totalitarizma [The Origins of totalitarianism]. Moscow.
3. Bernajs E., 2013. Inzheneriya soglasiya [Engineering of consent]. Polis [POLIS]. № 4.
4. Brodel. F. 2007. Material'naya civilizaciya, ehkonomika i kapitalizm, XV-XVIII. Т. 3. Vremya Mira [Material civilization, economics and capitalism, XV-XVIII. Vol. 3. Time of the World.]. Moscow.
5. Vsemirnaya Istoriya. T. 5 [World History. Vol. 5]. 2019. Mir v XIX veke [The world in the XIX century]. Moscow.
6. Gercen A.I., 1956. Sobranie sochinenij v 30 tomakh. T. 10 [Collected works in 30 volumes. Vol. 10]. Moscow.
7. Gercen A.I., 1956. Sobranie sochinenij v 30 tomakh. T. 12 [Collected works in 30 volumes. Vol. 12]. Moscow.
8. Danilevskij N.Ya., 2011. Rossiya i Evropa [Russia and Europe]. Moscow.
9. Dushenko K.V., 2024. “Rusofobiya” v ryadu prochikh fobij i manij: iz istorii politicheskogo yazyka [“Russophobia” among other phobias and manias: from the history of political language]. Moscow.
10. Zajonchkovskij A.M., 2002. Vostochnaya Vojna 1853-1856. T. 1 [The Eastern War of 1853-1856. Vol. 1]. Saint Peterburg.
11. Ivanova G.M., 2006. Istoriya GULAGa, 1918 - 1958: social'no-ehkonomicheskij i politiko-pravovoj aspekty [The History of the GULAG, 1918 - 1958: socio-economic, political and legal aspects]. Moscow.
12. Istoriya russkoj zhurnalistiki XVIII–XIX vekov 1973 [The History of Russian journalism of the XVIII–XIX centuries]. Ed. by professor A.V. Zapadov. Moscow.
13. Kirsh A., 2016. Bendzhamin Dizraehli [Benjamin Disraeli]. Moscow.
14. Kryzhko E.V., Pashkovskij P.I., 2024. Regional'noe izmerenie «Bol'shoj igry»: stanovlenie i razvitie (kon. XVIII – ser. XIX vv.) [ The regional dimension of the "Big Game": formation and development (con. XVIII – ser. XIX century)]. Konfliktologiya / nota bene [Conflictology / nota bene]. № 4.
15. Lasswell G.D., 2021. Tekhnika propagandy v mirovoj vojne [Propaganda techniques in the World War]. Moscow.
16. Mackinder H., 2006. Kruglaya zemlya i obretenie mira [Round Earth and the finding of peace]. Kosmopolis [Cosmopolis]. № 2(16).
17. Marks K., Engels F., 2024. Krymskaya vojna. Materialy iz gazetnykh statej. V 3 tomakh [The Crimean War. Materials from newspaper articles. In 3 volumes]. Ed. by N. Timoshenko. Moscow.
18. Marks Κ., Engels F., 1974. Manifest Kommunisticheskoj partii [Manifesto of the Communist Party]. Moscow.
19. Marks K., Engels F., 1958. Sochineniya. T. 10 [The Essays. Vol. 10]. Moscow.
20. Mel'nikova L.V., 2008. Svyatye mesta v centre Vostochnogo voprosa: cerkovno-politicheskij faktor kak odna iz prichin Krymskoj vojny [Holy places in the center of the Eastern question: the church-political factor as one of the causes of the Crimean War]. Voprosy istorii [Questions of History]. № 11.
21. Tarle E.V., 2024. Krymskaya vojna. Т. 1 [The Crimean War. Vol. 1]. Moscow.
22. Tarle E.V., 2024. Krymskaya vojna. Т. 2 [The Crimean War. Vol. 2]. Moscow.
23. Toynbee A., 2019. Postizhenie istorii [A Study of History]. Moscow.
24. Figes O., 2021. Krym. Poslednij krestovyj pokhod [Crimea: The Last Crusade]. Moscow.
25. Hantington S., 2003. Stolknovenie civilizacij [The Clash of Civilizations]. Moscow.
26. Chimarov S.Yu., 2015. Marks i Ehngel's o Rossii i russkoj armii v Krymskoj vojne 1853-1856 gg. [Marx and Engels on Russia and the Russian army in the Crimean War of 1853-1856]. Upravlencheskoe konsul'tirovanie. [Management Consulting]. № 2.
27. Spengler O., 2017. Zakat Zapadnogo mira [The decline of the West]. Moscow.
28. Capefigue J., 1855. Histoire des gгаndеs орегаtiоns financieres [History of financial governance]. Vol. 3: Banque, Вourses, Emprunts [Bank, Stocks, Loans]. Paris.
29. Evans G.L., 1828. On the Design of Russia. London.
30. Figes O., 2011. Crimea War: a history. New York.
31. Fitzgibbons J., 2008. Cromwell’s Head. London.
32. Fromkin D., 1980. The Great Game in Asia. Foreign Affairs. Vol. 58. No. 4.
33. Gleason J.H., 1950. The Genesis of Russophobia in Great Britain: A Study of the Interaction of Policy and Opinion. Cambridge.
34. Golovin I., 1854. The nations of Russia and Turkey and their destiny. London.
35. Hobson J.A., 2005. Imperialism: A study. New York.
36. Karl Marx und Friedrich Engels [Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels]. 1963. Werke. Berlin.
37. Kohn G.C., 2007. Dictionary of Wars. New York.
38. Mackinder H.J., 1919. Democratic ideals and reality. New York.
39. Roth С., 1978. A history of the Jews in England. London.
40. Séguin P., 2011. Louis Napoléon le grand [Louis Napoleon the Great]. Paris.
41. The later correspondence of Lord John Russel 1840-1878. 1925. Vol. II. London.
Review
For citations:
Koshmarov M.Yu. Propaganda Techniques and the Engineering of Consent in the West's Civilizational War Against Russia During the Crimean War. Journal of Law and Administration. 2025;21(3):3-16. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2025-3-76-3-16





















