Preview

Journal of Law and Administration

Advanced search

Philosophical and Legal Understanding of the Concepts: Image, Icon, Image, Honesty, Reputation, Their Manifestations in Criminal Procedural Law

https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2023-1-66-3-14

Abstract

Introduction. The article presents an attempt for the first time, on the basis of philosophical and legal understanding, to use the concept of “reputation”, which is new for legal scientific circulation. Legal terms, including criminal procedural ones, arise as generic terms. That is, concepts are brought under a common genus, and then specific differences are distinguished. Philosophical categories, due to their universality, cannot be summed up under the genus, and, as a rule, act as a dialectical pair of opposites the thesis and antithesis. Such, for example, are the concepts of essence and phenomenon, necessity and chance, content and form. The complexity of introducing a new concept of reputation into scientific circulation lies in the fact that it does not have its own dialectical antithesis. A bad reputation is also a reputation. At a stretch, reputation can be opposed to discredit, but discredit is an action aimed at undermining reputation, and this is a transition to another kind. Concepts of this kind can be meaningful by analogy. As such, the authors chose the dialectical pair icon image, like foreign-language tracing papers from the Russian word image, which in the legal sense are reduced to reputation. Both that and another (both an icon and an image) are an image, but how different and even opposite are the meanings of these words. Moreover, initially the intentions of the authors were precisely linguistic (and not religious or marketing), and only then the words themselves designated the cultural area of their application.
Materials and methods. The theoretical and methodological basis of the study was the hermeneutical approach to the analysis of the concept of "reputation". Methods of systematic, comparative legal analysis, special philosophical and legal research tools were used. The authors used examples from various areas of law criminal procedure, criminal, civil.
Research results. Based on the results of the analysis, the question of trust is raised in relation to the procedural status of participants in criminal proceedings. The introduction of the concept of "reputation" as a legal category into legal circulation is proposed.
Discussion and conclusion. In the form of a legislative novel, the presumption of good faith of a participant in criminal proceedings is formulated.
Presumption of good faith:
Everyone is considered conscientious and reasonable, until otherwise is proved in the manner prescribed by this Code and established by a judicial act that has entered into legal force.
Everyone is not obliged to prove their conscientiousness and reasonableness. The burden of proving dishonesty, unreasonableness, abuse of right lies with the person who claims the opposite.
All doubts about the good faith and reasonableness of a person that cannot be eliminated in the manner prescribed by this Code shall be interpreted in favor of the person whose reputation is questioned.
Any procedural actions and (or) decisions of a state body or an official in the field of criminal proceedings, even based on assumptions, cannot be based solely on the fact that a person has a certain procedural status in a case under consideration or another. 

About the Authors

G. V. Sofronov
Ural State Law University named after V.F.Yakovlev
Russian Federation

Gleb V. Sofronov, PhD in Law, Associate Professor of the Department of Judicial Activity and Criminal Procedure



R. N. Kholstinin
Ural State Law University named after V.F. Yakovlev
Russian Federation

Robert N. Kholstinin, Senior Lecturer of the Department of Social and Humanitarian Disciplines



References

1. Bolshoy Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar. 2000 [A large Encyclopedic dictionary]. Academic.ru. URL: https://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/dmitriev/4641

2. Bytie. Bibliya. Vetkhiy Zavet [Genesis. The Bible. The Old Testament]. Chapter 25. Verse 29-34.

3. Vinnitsky, A.V., 2020. Prodolzhenie diskussii ob administrativnoy otvetstvennosti arbitrazhnykh upravlyayushchikh v svete podgotovki proekta novogo KoAP [Continuation of the discussion on the administrative responsibility of arbitration managers in the light of the preparation of the draft of the new Administrative Code]. Administrativnoe i munitsipalnoe pravo [Administrative and municipal law]. No. 2. Р. 1-15.

4. Godfroy, J., 1992. Chto takoe psikhologiya. Vol. 1 [What is psychology]. Moscow.

5. Evangelie po Matfeyu. Bibliya. Novyy Zavet [The Gospel according to Matthew. The Bible. The New Testament]. Chapter 6. Verse 24.

6. Lidov, A., 2010. Ikona i ikonicheskoe v sakralnom prostranstve [Icon and the iconic in the sacred space]. Polit.ru. URL: http: www.polit.ru/lectures/2010/07/16/icon.html

7. Martynov, V., 2007. «Muzyka i pismo». ["Music and writing"]. Polit.ru. URL: http:.www.polit.ru/article/2007/10/05/martynov

8. Motorin, A.V., 2010. Russkiy «obraz», grecheskaya «ikona» i zapadnyy «imidzh». [Russian "image", Greek "icon" and Western "image".] Rossiyskiy pravoslavnyy informatsionnyy internet-portal «Pravoslávie.Ru» [Russian Orthodox information Internet portal "Orthodoxy.Ru»]. URL: http:.www.pravoslavie.ru/34145.html

9. Noveyshiy filosofskiy slovar. 2003. [The newest Philosophical Dictionary.]. Minsk.

10. Pivovarov D., Kemerov V. 1998. NAGLYADNOST [VISIBILITY]. Filosofskaya entsiklopediya. "Panprint". Natsionalnaya entsiklopedicheskaya sluzhba Rossii (NES) – otkrytyy obrazovatelnyy resurs [Philosophical Encyclopedia "Panprint". National Encyclopedic Service of Russia (NES) – an open educational resource]. URL: http: terme.ru/dictionary/183/word/nagljadnost

11. Sofronov, G.V., Kholstinin, R.N., 2019. Stremlenie k istine kak dominanta razvitiya ugolovno-protsessualnogo dokazatelstvennogo prava [The pursuit of truth as a dominant in the development of criminal procedural evidentiary law]. Rossiyskiy yuridicheskiy zhurnal [Russian Law Journal]. No. 2 Р. 108-115.

12. Sofronov, G.V., 2021. Podotraslevaya struktura ugolovnogo protsessa. Prokuratura Rossiyskoy Federatsii: vektor razvitiya i rol v formirovanii demokraticheskogo pravovogo gosudarstva [Sub-sectoral structure of the criminal process. Prosecutor's Office of the Russian Federation: vector of development and role in the formation of a democratic rule of law]. Sbornik materialov Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-prakticheskoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy 300-letiyu prokuratury Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Collection of materials of the International scientific and Practical conference dedicated to the 300th anniversary of the Prosecutor's Office of the Russian Federation]. Part 2. Р. 229-234.

13. Chudinov, A.N., 1910. Slovar inostrannykh slov, voshedshikh v sostav russkogo yazyka. [Dictionary of foreign words included in the Russian language]. Academic.ru. URL: https:.dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/dmitriev/4641


Review

For citations:


Sofronov G.V., Kholstinin R.N. Philosophical and Legal Understanding of the Concepts: Image, Icon, Image, Honesty, Reputation, Their Manifestations in Criminal Procedural Law. Journal of Law and Administration. 2023;19(1):3-14. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2023-1-66-3-14

Views: 322


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2073-8420 (Print)
ISSN 2587-5736 (Online)