Preview

Journal of Law and Administration

Advanced search

FOREIGN CITIZENS` ACTIVITY UNDER A CIVIL LAW CONTRACT

https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2017-3-44-15-21

Abstract

Introduction. Adoption of a separate chapter regulating employment of foreign citizens in the body of the Labor Code of Russia (LC) has become a significant amendment of the recent years. At the same time, the Russian law also sets forth the employment of foreigners under a civil law agreement. Specifics of this kind of legal relations have not been reflected in the civil legislation. Current state of affairs entails certain difficulties in practice. This study is aimed at the justification of the necessity to develop a concept of foreign citizens` employment in the civil law framework. In this connection, an analysis on the legal nature of the work and labor agreement has been conducted with a view to differentiating such an agreement from the employment contract, as well as to highlighting the grounds of the work and labor relations with a foreign citizen.

Materials and methods. The methodological basis of the research constitute such general scientific and special cognitive methods in the sphere of private international law as analysis and synthesis of social and legal phenomena; system-structural analysis; the formal-logical method; the method of comparative law.

Results of the study. Results of the analysis reveal that labor activity conducted under a work contract is a widespread practice, particularly among foreign citizens. At the same time both employment agreement and work agreement should reflect the specific status of foreign citizens, since such gaps in law create plentiful difficulties for parties in such legal relations.

Discussion and conclusions: the article substantiates the idea that the inclusion of separate chapters setting forth the special status of foreign persons conducting activities under a civil law contract to the body of the Civil Code of the Russia seems to be the most optimal solution. The absence of such codification and the conflict of norms applied in foreign labor regulation impede the proper implementation of subjective rights by the given persons and often do not allow them to opt for entering into work and labor agreement.

About the Authors

A. I. Ivanchak
MGIMO (University) under the Ministry оf Foreign Affairs of Russia
Russian Federation

Doctor of Science (Law), Full Professor; Professor with the Department of International Private and Civil Law



O. V. Kravchenko
MGIMO (University) under the Ministry оf Foreign Affairs of Russia
Russian Federation
Master`s Course Student, Department of International Private and Civil Law


References

1. Vechkanov G.S., 1995. Migracija naselenija kak faktor formirovanija trudovyh resursov [Migration of the Population as a Formation Factor of Labor Resources]. Problemy trudovyh resursov RF (social’no-jekonomicheskoe issledovanie) [Labor Resources Issues in Russia (socio-economic study)]. Spb.

2. Ivanchak A.I., 2012. Pravovoj status inostrannogo grazhdanina v sfere truda: ponjatie i struktura [The Legal Status of a Foreign Citizen in the Sphere of Labor: Concept and Structure]. Pravo i upravlenie. XXI vek [Journal of Law and Administration]. № 1 (22).

3. Ivanchak A.I., 2014. Princip nacional’nogo rezhima kak osnova pravovogo statusa inostrannogo rabotnika [The Principle of National Treatment as the Basis for the Legal Status of a Foreign Worker]. Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava [Moscow Journal of International Law]. № 1(93).

4. Habrieva T.Ja., 2015. Pravovaja sistema Rossijskoj Federacii v uslovijah mezhdunarodnoj integracii [Russian Legal System under Conditions of International Integration]. Vestnik rossijskoj akademii nauk [Bulletin of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. № 3.

5. Habrieva T.Ja., 2015. Osnovnye vektory i problemy razvitija social’nogo zakonodatel’stva [Main Vectors and Problems of the Social Legislation Development]. Pravo i social’noe razvitie: novaja gumanisticheskaja ierarhija cennostej [Law and Social Development: New Humanistic Hierarchy of Values]. Otv. red. A.V. Gabov, N.V. Putilo. Moscow, Dostupno v SPS Konsul’tantPljus.

6. Capenko I.P., 2015. Social’nye jeffekty immigracii [Social Consequences of Immigration]. Vestnik rossijskoj akademii nauk [Bulletin of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. № 10.

7. Cahuc Pierre, Kramarz Pierre., 2004. De la précarité vers une sécurité sociale professionnelle [From Precariousness to Professional Social Security]. Presses Universitaires de France [French University Press]. Paris.

8. Thiollet Jean-Pierre, 1999. Baux commerciaux et professionnels [About Commercial and Professional Hire]. Axiome éditions [Axiome Edition]. Paris.

9. Yengibaryan, R., 2014. Ethnicity and citizenship as key factors shaping human personality and behavior. Giornale di Storia Costituzionale [The Journal of Constitution History]. Volume 27.


Review

For citations:


Ivanchak A.I., Kravchenko O.V. FOREIGN CITIZENS` ACTIVITY UNDER A CIVIL LAW CONTRACT. Journal of Law and Administration. 2017;(3):15-21. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2017-3-44-15-21

Views: 512


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 2073-8420 (Print)
ISSN 2587-5736 (Online)