The Prerequisites for the Establishment of the Legal Status of Workers in Mexico
https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2025-2-75-63-73
Abstract
Introduction. The establishment of the legal status of workers in Mexico is commonly associated with the adoption of the 1917 Constitution, which enshrined the foundations of labor legislation during the Mexican Revolution. However, the prerequisites for its formation developed throughout Mexican history, including prior to Spanish colonization, during the colonial period, and during the independence era. In both Russian and international historical-legal scholarship, there is still no comprehensive study on this topic. The aim of this research is to analyze the evolution of the legal status of workers in Mexico before the 1910–1917 revolution, identifying the interconnections between socio-economic processes, legislative acts, and the transformation of labor relations.
Materials and Methods. This research employs dialectical, formal-legal, and systemic methods, which enable the integration of theoretical analysis of legal norms with their historical context. The study draws on works by both Russian and foreign authors dedicated to the evolution of labor relations and the legal status of workers in Mexico, as well as on legislative acts and legal treatises including Sentimientos de la Nación (1813), Decreto Constitucional para la Libertad de la América Mexicana (1814), the Plan de Iguala (1821), Reglamento Provisional Político del Imperio Mexicano (1822), the Constitution of Mexico of 1857, Decreto sobre la libertad del trabajo en la clase de jornaleros (1865), and Estatuto Provisional del Imperio Mexicano (1965). This legal-historical analysis is further enriched by an examination of the socio-economic conditions prevalent in each period.
Research Results. The establishment of the legal status of workers emerged as the outcome of a centuries- long evolutionary process. In the pre-colonial era, labor relations were based on rigid social hierarchies and forced labor. Although the Laws of the Indies formally guaranteed certain rights to indigenous peoples, colonial society inherited many pre-colonial principles, and in practice, the exploitation of the native population persisted. The period of independence in the 19th century abolished the institutions of encomienda and peonage, proclaimed the equality of citizens, yet failed to establish mechanisms for the protection of rights. Legislative initiatives from 1856 to 1910 laid the foundations for regulating labor relations, while the Porfiriato era served as a catalyst for the emerging movement for workers’ rights.
Discussion and Conclusion. The key conclusion of the study is the continuity between the early forms of labor regulation and the provisions of the 1917 Constitution, which ultimately codified the legal status of workers in Mexico. This research confirms that the evolution of labor law in Mexico reflects a synthesis of longstanding traditions and the "spirit of the people." The findings are significant for understanding the genesis of labor rights and offer potential applications in comparative legal studies
About the Author
A. V. ChasovskoiRussian Federation
Andrei V. Chasovskoi, Postgraduate student, the Department of Legal Theory and Comparative Law
References
1. Baglaj V.E., 1998. Atsteki: istorija, ekonomika, sotsial'no-politicheskij stroj (dokolonial. period) [Aztecs: history, economy, socio-political structure (pre-colonial period)]. Moscow.
2. Selivanova I.V., 2020. Meksikanskije konstitutsionnyje proekty nachala XIX veka [Mexican constitutional projects of the early 19th century]. Latinskaja Amerika [Latin America]. 2020. № 5. Р. 81-91.
3. Buen Lozano N.d., 1994. Derecho del Trabajo. Derecho Individual. Derecho Colectivo. Tomo Segundo [Labor Law. Individual Law. Collective Law. Volume Two]. 11th ed., Mexico.
4. Casas B.d.l., 2011. Brevísima relación de la destrucción de las Indias [A Brief Account of the Destruction of the Indies]. Ed. Martínez Torrejón J.M. Colombia.
5. Castorena J., 1942. Tratado de Derecho obrero [Treatise on Labor Law]. Mexico.
6. Cueva M.d.l., 1972. El nuevo derecho mexicano del trabajo: Historia, principios fundamentales, derecho individual y trabajos especiales [The New Mexican Labor Law: History, Fundamental Principles, Individual Law and Special Works]. Mexico.
7. García Añoveros J.M., 1982. La fuerza de trabajo del indígena americano en las épocas prehispánicas y virreinal [The Workforce of the American Indigenous in Pre-Hispanic and Viceregal Times]. Quinto Centenario [Quincentenary]. № 3. Р. 87-108.
8. Marquet G.P., 2014. Fuentes y antecedentes del derecho mexicano del trabajo [Sources and Background of Mexican Labor Law]. In: Derechos humanos en el trabajo y la seguridad social. Liber Amicorum: en homenaje al doctor Jorge Carpizo [Human Rights in Work and Social Security. Liber Amicorum: in homage to Doctor Jorge Carpizo]. Ed. Kurczyn Villalobos P. Mexico, Р. 243-280.
9. Miranda J.d., 2018. El tributo indígena en la Nueva España durante el siglo XVI [The Indigenous Tribute in New Spain during the 16th Century]. Digital edition based on the 1st edition, 1st reprint, Mexico: El Colegio de México, 1980. Alicante.
10. Ots Capdequi J.M., 1969. Historia del derecho español en América y del derecho indiano [History of Spanish Law in America and Indian Law]. Madrid.
11. Padden R.C., 1967. The Hummingbird and the Hawk: Conquest and Sovereignty in the Valley of Mexico, 1503-1541. Columbus: Ohio State University Press.
12. Semo Calev E., 1978. Historia mexicana: economía y lucha de clases [Mexican History: Economy and Class Struggle]. Mexico.
13. Tena Ramírez F., 1973. Leyes fundamentales de México, 1808-1973 [Fundamental Laws of Mexico, 1808-1973]. Mexico.
14. Venegas Ramírez C., 1968. La Asistencia Hospitalaria para Indios en la Nueva España [Hospital Assistance for Indians in New Spain]. Anales Del Instituto Nacional De Antropología E Historia [Annals of the National Institute of Anthropology and History]. № 6(19). Р. 227-240.
15. Zarco F., 1990. Historia del Congreso Extraordinario Constituyente de 1856 y 1857, Tomo I [History of the Extraordinary Constituent Congress of 1856 and 1857, Volume I]. Mexico: Cámara de Diputados, LIV Legislatura, Comité de Asuntos Editoriales (Original work published 1857).
Review
For citations:
Chasovskoi A.V. The Prerequisites for the Establishment of the Legal Status of Workers in Mexico. Journal of Law and Administration. 2025;21(2):63-73. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2025-2-75-63-73