The myth role in current identification programs: studying law remythologization in the scientific and educational field in modern Russia
https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2018-4-49-12-20
Abstract
Introduction. The article analyzes the issue of the myth role in identification programs of individual and group types, corresponding to ethnic law activation at the level of educational and research institutions. The availability of cultural centers conducting studies in the field of customs and traditions researches (e.g. in studying national languages) shows citizens' interest in “home area" ideas, specification of their position in general civil identification pattern and correlation between ethnic and civil law. The author puts a question of correlation between legal awareness types and law politization process (including educational subject), examines correlation between ideological projections of various research approaches and those research approaches themselves.
Materials and methods. The material for the scientific study were the projects and programs which are used in teaching and researching ethnic law and legal philosophy in various educational and research institutions in Russia, as well as scientific results of those institutions' activities presented in books and articles and popular-scientific literature. The methodological foundation of the research is the horizontal and vertical comparative study method enabling us to understand correlation between various educational subjects concerned with ethnic law. This method also allows tracing their genesis and current state by key points affecting identification preferences.
Research results. The article shows that law remythologization in the scientific and educational field in modern Russia is a consequence of the promotion of social and cultural processes at the regional and local levels. They were triggered by a conditional decentralization due to political reforms over the last thirty years and their result was an increased interest in national languages, culture and traditions. All these phenomena have a particular scientific and academic significance, as well as (under certain circumstances) an ideological meaning. As a result law remythologization, on the one hand, is a solid base for civil legal awareness filling its formalized directions with a meaning picked up from direct communication between people. On the other hand, accentuation on archaic forms of social relations regulation by means of ethnic law may contribute to dramatic intensification of regionalization tendencies. Thus dynamic balance between law and tradition calls for regular efforts for adjustment of corresponding educational programmes and for training highly qualified teachers capable of working with various students categories.
Discussion and conclusion. The article points out and describes the basic directions of legal philosophy development in connection with legal anthropology, shows possible ways of improving educational programmes taking into consideration the ideological influence of the ideological ethnic law interpretation vector which may have an impact upon students' awareness. A special importance in this context is to be given to civil law teaching, as well to philosophy and complementary disciplines promoting forming a conscious social positioning.
About the Author
M. V. SilantievaRussian Federation
Margarita V. Silantieva - Doctor of Philosophy, Professor, Head of the Departmnet of Philosophy named after A.F. Shishkin
References
1. Arzumanov, I.A., 2013. IdeologicheskiJ element pravovoJ sistemy: k voprosu o metodologicheskikh dominantakh strukturnogo analiza [The ideological element of the legal system: on the issue of methodological dominants of structural analysis]. Pravovaia sistema Rossii: traditsii i novatsii. Materialy X VserossiJskd nauchno-teoreticheskd konferentsii [The legal system of Russia: traditions and innovations. Proceedings of the X Russian Scientific-Theoretical Conference], Edited by N.S. Nizhnik. Saint-Petersburg.
2. Arzumanov, I.A., Ganusenko, I.V., Kazarin, V.N., 2014. Gosudarstvennoe pravo Rossnskoi imperii: osobennosti normativnogo zakrepleniia otdelnykh institutov [State law of the Russian Empire: peculiarities of regulatory consolidation of some institutions]. Irkutsk.
3. Baranov, V.M., Ovchinnikov, A.I., Samarin, A.A., 2017. Eksterritorialnoe prostranstvo prava. Monografiia [Extraterritorial space of law. Monograph]. Moscow.
4. Velichko, A.M., 2002. Nravstvennye i natsional'nye osnovy prava: sbornik statei po filosofii i istorii prava [Moral and national principles of law: a collection of articles on the philosophy and history of law]. Saint-Petersburg.
5. Viktorin, V.M., 2008. Obychnoe pravo i vlast - «potestarnost» etnotraditsionnom i mezhdistsiplinarno-issledovatelskom kontekstakh [Common law and authority - "potestary" in ethno-traditional and interdisciplinary research contexts]. Panorama Evrazii. Nauchnyj, obshchestvenno-poiiticheskif zhumal [Panorama of Eurasia. Scientific, social and political journal]. No 1.
6. Galperin, S.D., 1893. Ocherki pervobytnogo prava [Essays on primitive law]. Saint-Petersburg.
7. Glagolev, V.S., 2011. Modeli adaptatsii etnicheskikh struktur k globalizatsionnym vyzovam sovremennosti [Models of adaptation of ethnic structures to the globalization challenges of our time]. Aktualnye problemy istorii i etnoiogii. Materiaiy Vserossifskoi nauchno-prakticheskof konferentsii, posviashchennoi 70-ietiiu so dnia rozhdeniia R.Z. Ianguzina i 20-letiiu kafedry istorii RB i etnoiogii [Actual problems of history and ethnology. Materials of the Russian Scientific and Practical Conference dedicated to the 70th anniversary of R.Z. Yanguzin and the 20th anniversary of the Department of History of the Republic of Bashkortostan and Ethnology], Ufa.
8. Glagolev, V.S., 2015. Pravovaia kultura v sisteme natsionalnykh tsennostei [Legal culture in the system of national values]. Pravo i upravlenie: XXI vek [Journal of Law and Administration], No 4 (37).
9. Guseinov, Iu.M., 2017. Normy adata i shariata v obriadakh i obychaiakh, sviazannykh s rozhdeniem i vospitaniem detei u kumykov v XIX - nachale XX veka [Norms of adat and sharia in ceremonies and customs related to the birth and bringing up of children among the Kumyks in the XIX - early XX century]. PrepodavatelXXI vek[Prepodavatel XXI vek. Russian Journal of Education], No 4-1.
10. Dianina, S.Iu., 2015. Ubiistva chesti v kontekst multikulturalizma: kultura mozhet ubivat? [Honor killings in the context of multiculturalism: can culture kill?]. Voprosy kulturologii [Interdisciplinary researches of culture]. No 1.
11. Dubovitskaia, O.N., 2011. Sushchnost prava v teorii pravogeneza [The essence of law in the theory of legal genesis]. Vestnik Tambovskogo universiteta. Seriia: Gumanitamye nauki [Tambov University Review. Series Humanities], No 10 (102).
12. Dumanov, Kh.M., Pershits, A.I., 2001. Mononormatika i nachalnoe pravo (statia vtoraia) [Mononormative system and elementary law. Second article]. Gosudarstvo i pravo [State and Law]. No 9.
13. Dumanov, Kh.M., Pershits, A.I., 2000. Mononormatika i nachalnoe pravo (stat'ia pervaia) [Mononormative system and elementary law. First article]. Gosudarstvo ipravo [State and Law]. No 1.
14. Zarema, Z.M., 2010. Vliianie obychno-pravovykh reguliatorov na gosudarstvenno-pravovoe razvitie Severnogo Kavkaza: istoriko-pravovoi aspekt [The influence of customary legal regulators on the state-legal development of the North Caucasus: historical and legal aspect]. Iurist"-Pravoved"[Legislator-Lawyer]. No 4.
15. Zenko, M.A., 1997. K probleme izucheniia obychnogo prava u aborigenov Zapadnoi Sibiri [To the problem of studying of common law among the aborigional people of West Siberia]. Vestnikarkheologii, antropologiii etnografii [Archeology, anthropology and ethnography review]. No 1.
16. Ivannikov, I.A., 1999. Mesto obychnogo prava v pravovoi kul'ture rossnskogo obshchestva [Place of common law in the legal culture of Russian society]. Obychnoe pravo v Rossii: problemy istorii, teorii i praktiki [Common law in Russia: problems of history, theory and practice], Rostov-on-Don.
17. Kovalevskii, M.M., 1886. Pervobytnoe pravo [Primitive law]. Moscow.
18. Kovler, A.I., 2002. Antropologiia prava [Anthropology of law]. Moscow.
19. Ladyzhenskii, A.M., 1995. Metody etnologicheskogo izucheniia prava [Methods of ethnological study of law]. Etnograficheskoe obozrenie [Ethnographic Review], No 4.
20. Moiseenkova, S.A., 2015. Antropologicheski-pravovye determinanty pravoobrazovaniia [Anthropological and legal determinants of the genesis of law]. Visnik Nacionalnogo universitetu «Lvivska poiitehnika». Seria: Uridicni nauki. [Bulletin of the Lviv Polytechnic National University. Series: Law Sciences], No 824 (6).
21. Mokshina, Iu.N., 2005. Antropologiia prava v sisteme vysshego iuridicheskogo obrazovaniia (na primere etnonormatiki u mordvy) [Anthropology of law in the system of higher juridical education (ethnonormative process of the Mordvins as an example)]. Integratsiia obrazovaniia [Integration of education]. No 3.
22. Musaeva, D.Iu., 2013. Transformatsiia institutov obychnogo prava narodov Dagestana. Ishkil [Transformation of the common law institutes of the peoples of Dagestan. Ishkil]. Severo-Kavkazskif iuridicheskif vestnik [North Caucasus Legal Vestnik], No 2.
23. Obychnoe pravo i pravovoi pliuralizm. Materialy XI Mezhdunarodnogo kongressa po obychnomu pravu i pravovomu pliuralizmu. Moskva, avgust 1997 [Common law and legal pluralism. Materials of the XI International Congress on Common Law and Legal Pluralism. Moscow, August 1997]. Edited by N.I. Novikova, V.A. Tishkov. Moscow, 1999.
24. Odaev, Kh.M., 2012. Sotsialno-eticheskaia rol musulmanskogo prava (fikkh) v obshchestvenno-politicheskoi zhizni Chechni (konets ХХ - nachalo XXI vv.) [The socio-ethical role of Muslim law (fiqh) in the social and political life of Chechnya (late XX - early XXI centuries)]. Thesis PhD (Philosophy). Moscow.
25. Osmanova, M.Kh., 2008. Obychnoe pravo i vospitanie pravovoi kultury uchashchikhsia [The common law and development of the legal culture of students]. Izvestiia DGPU. Psikhoiogo-pedagogicheskie nauki [Dagestan State Pedagogical University Journal. Psychological and pedagogical sciences]. No 3.
26. Pershits, A.I., Smirnova, A.S., 1998. Iuridicheskn pliuralizm narodov Severnogo Kavkaza [Legal pluralism of the peoples of the North Caucasus]. Obshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost [Social sciences and contemporary world], No 1.
27. Pravovaia zhizn obshchestva: problemy teorii i praktiki. Monografiia [The legal life of society: problems of theory and practice. Monograph]. Edited by A.V. Malko. Moscow, 2015.
28. Rulan, N., 1999. Iuridicheskaia antropologiia [Legal anthropology]. Moscow.
29. Semenov, Iu.I., 2000. Obshchie problemy normativnoi etnologii i materialy po normativnoi kulture narodov Severnoi Evrazii i Dalnego Vostoka (nentsy, mansi, khanty, kety, selkupy, nganasany, evenki, eveny, iukagiry, kariaki, chuktsi, itelmeny, negidaltsy, orochi, oroki, ulchi, nanaitsy, udegeitsy, nivkhi, ainy [Common problems of normative ethnology and materials on the normative culture of the peoples of Northern Eurasia and the Far East (Nenets, Mansi, Khanty, Ket, Selkup, Nganasans, Evenks, Evens, Yukagirs, Karyaks, Chukchi, Itelmens, Negidals, Orochi, Oroki, Ulchi, Nanai, Udege, Nivhi, Ainu]. Traditsionnaia normativnaia kuitura, organizatsiia vlasti i ekonomika narodov Severnoi Evrazii i Dal'nego Vostoka [Traditional normative culture, organization of power and economy of the peoples of Northern Eurasia and the Far East]. Edited by Iu.I. Semenov. Moscow.
30. Sokolovskii, S.V., 2000. O vozmozhnostiakh dialoga mezhdu iuristami i antropologami [On the possibilities of dialogue between lawyers and anthropologists]. Iuridicheskaia antropologiia. Zakon i zhizn [Legal anthropology. Law and life], Moscow.
31. Sushkova, Iu.N., 2017. Metodologiia iuridicheskoi antropologii [Methodology of legal anthropology]. Sotsialno-politicheskie nauki [Sociopolitical Sciences], No 1.
32. Sushkova, Iu.N., 2009. Etnopravosudie u mordvy [Ethnic judgment of the Mordovians]. Thesis D.Sc. (Historical Sciences). Saransk.
33. Tishkov, V.A., 2000. Antropologiia prava - nachalo i evoliutsiia distsipliny [Anthropology of law - the beginning and evolution of the discipline]. Iuridicheskaia antropologiia. Zakon i zhizn [Legal anthropology. Law and life], Moscow.
34. Tishkov, V.A., 1999. Etnichnost, pravo i zakon [Ethnicity, Law and Enactment]. Chelovek i pravo: kniga o Letnei shkole po iuridicheskoi antropologii [Man and Law: A Book about the Summer School on Legal Anthropology]. Moscow.
35. Falaleeva, I.N., 2004. Iuridicheskaia antropologiia. Metodicheskie rekomendatsii dlia studentov iuridicheskogo fakulteta [Legal anthropology. Methodical recommendations for law students]. Volgograd. URL: http://window.edu.ru/resource/810/25810/files/volsu391.pdf
36. Shapsugov, D.Iu., 2010. Pravogenez u narodov Severnogo Kavkaza: «Respublikanskaia» i «Monarkhicheskaia» modeli formirovaniia prava (postanovka problemy) [Legal genesis of the peoples of the North Caucasus: the "Republican" and "Monarchic" models of the formation of law (problem statement)]. Severo-Kavkazsku iuridicheskii vestnik[North Caucasus Legal Vestnik], No 3.
37. Shchipkov, V.A., 2017. Regionalizm kak ideologiia globalizma [The ideology of regionalism as a socio-cultural technology of the globalizing world]. Kontsept: fiiosofiia, religiia, kuitura [Concept: philosophy, religion, culture], No 3.
38. Iuridicheskaia antropologiia. Zakon i zhizn [Legal anthropology. Law and life]. Moscow, 2000.
Review
For citations:
Silantieva M.V. The myth role in current identification programs: studying law remythologization in the scientific and educational field in modern Russia. Journal of Law and Administration. 2018;(4):12-20. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2073-8420-2018-4-49-12-20